DECLASSIFIED // COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Source: DOJ Dataset 9 / EFTA00724539.pdf
RECIPE EVOLUTION DOSSIER

The Original JE Muffin
From Whole Wheat to Almond Flour

Forensic analysis reveals two distinct formulations. The J.E.E. "Operating Manual" contained the original whole wheat recipe. Later communications show a shift to almond flour — the version that became infamous.

Original — Operating Manual

The First Formula

Source: J.E.E. Operating Manual (EFTA00724539.pdf)

Muffin Batter

  • Extra-large eggs4
  • Olive oil1 cup
  • Dark brown sugar½ cup
  • Whole wheat flour ★7 cups
  • Whole milk (organic)4 cups
  • Digestive bran4 cups
  • Ground flax seed½ cup
  • Whole flax seed½ cup
  • Baking soda5 tsp
  • Salt¼ tsp
  • Raisins1 cup
  • Vanilla extract1 tsp

Topping Mix

  • • Pecans (equal parts)
  • • Walnuts (equal parts)
  • • Sliced almonds (equal parts)
  • • Whole flaxseed (equal parts)
  • • Flaxseed meal (equal parts)
Note: Operating Manual specified "NO SUGAR" in topping mix. All eggs and milk must be organic.
Final — The Infamous Version

The Final Formula

Source: Shuliak emails (EFTA00566791.pdf)

Muffin Batter

  • Large eggs (organic)4
  • Olive oil (organic)1 cup
  • Dark brown sugar½ cup
  • Almond flour ★7 cups
  • Whole milk (organic)4 cups
  • Digestive bran4 cups
  • Ground flax seed½ cup
  • Whole flax seed½ cup
  • Baking soda5 tsp
  • Salt¼ tsp
  • Raisins1 cup
  • Vanilla extract1 tsp

Topping Mix

  • • Pecans (equal parts)
  • • Walnuts (equal parts)
  • • Sliced almonds (equal parts)
  • • Whole flaxseed (equal parts)
  • • Flaxseed meal (equal parts)
Key Change: Whole wheat flour replaced with almond flour. This is the version shared with associates and praised in the "Ode to the Muffin."

Assembly Protocol

From the J.E.E. Operating Manual — applies to both versions

Preparation

  1. Preheat oven to 350°F (177°C). Grease muffin tin with Pam Spray.
  2. In a large bowl, combine bran, flour, flax seeds, baking soda, and salt.
  3. Beat eggs and dark brown sugar in electric mixer until thick and creamy.
  4. Add olive oil to egg/sugar mixture, mix to combine.
  5. Combine whole milk and vanilla, set aside.
  6. Add flour and milk mixture to egg mixture, alternating additions. Do NOT over beat.
  7. Add raisins and stir until incorporated.
  8. Pour into airtight container and refrigerate for 24 hours before using.

Baking

  1. Fill muffin tins to the top with mixture.
  2. Add topping mixture generously.
  3. Bake at 350°F for 35-45 minutes.
  4. Raw mixture keeps in refrigerator for 30 days.

Yield

Full recipe yields approximately 24 large muffins. Quarter the recipe for a standard batch of 6.

Sources: U.S. Department of Justice, Jeffrey Epstein Document Release

Dataset 9: EFTA00724539.pdf (Operating Manual), EFTA00566791.pdf (Final Recipe), EFTA00566799.pdf (Organic Requirements)

Recipe analysis adapted from Natalie Sandoval's investigation at stateoftheday.us

← Return to Briefing Room